One situation whose audacity I will probably never get over happened right after my second book was published. You may remember: "30 Minuten Second Brain" was published by GABAL Verlag in 2023. It's about how to build a network of knowledge, modelled on Niklas Luhmann's Zettelkasten.
I don't want to go into too much detail here, I've already written a few articles about it, for example about how I came to my Second Brain. It differs fundamentally from the approach of Tiago Forte, who became very well known with the title. His book was published in Germany only a few days before mine. My approach sorts less into silos, as the PARA method does, and builds on Niklas Luhmann's Zettelkasten and makes it usable for knowledge workers in today's age.
But I'm not exaggerating when I say that it fundamentally changed how I deal with knowledge.
The book was also meant to become a coaching programme. I started recording videos for it and offered the programme for sale.
Some time later, a woman approached me who offers online courses on all kinds of things herself. A real grab bag of visibility, positioning, content creation, marketing and so on. At first it looked as if a partnership could come out of it, and we gave each other access to our learning material.
But after a while, and after a few phone calls in which she asked explicit questions about the method and how she could apply it herself, she wrote to me in an email:
She copied my offer 1:1 and didn't even name me as her (inspiration) source. On the contrary, she told potential customers that she had worked for years on the best method for herself and had ultimately developed this approach.
I planned a session for an event with a colleague from the association. It was about value-based fees. My idea was not just to give a talk and explain how it works, but to turn it into a calculator as well, back then still in Excel.
Because I'm pretty good at that, I programmed that calculator. It took several days and several rounds of feedback, including with my colleague from the association. I spent nights on it, simply because I find the topic so important and wanted so much for it to get out into the world.
He then hosted the calculator in his own Digistore account. I didn't have a Digistore account at the time and was quite happy not to have to deal with that. He entered me there as a joint venture partner, and I received 50 percent of the revenue we generated with it.
Over time, he removed me, without telling me. No message, no explanation, nothing at all. I just stopped receiving statements, and of course no share either. I do have a version of the Excel file too, but the calculator is no longer with me. He no longer responds to my emails or calls about it. Whether he has since resold the calculator, I don't know.
The real trigger for this post arrived in the mail a few days ago. A real letter, not a personal one but a mass mailing. That actually makes it even cheekier. In it, the sender offers a consulting programme, and the website for it says: twelve months, positioning, a non-fiction book with a publisher and a fee system that includes a value-based fee calculator. That is a calculator I know, because I built it.
Well, I was speechless at first.
The last example happened only recently. I already told you about it in Freebie Mentality. I developed the software Calendar Butler and offer it. Plenty of freelancers are already on it, and some great partnerships are on the horizon. It is a good and stable thing that helps freelancers and was really born out of a problem.
In a meeting with a consulting company where I would love to see Calendar Butler in use, the contact person tells me: “I see two options for your software to run in our [specially secured and certified, author's note] environment. The first is that it sits on our servers, so you let the code run with us. Or the other option would be that we simply rebuild it.” It never occurred to him that this is a product with a small base of paying customers.
Of course I was angry for a moment. But that doesn't get me anywhere. In situations like this, my husband tells me something that is meant to pick me up again. And it does, because it turns my gaze forward again.
It lets me lift my head a little and breathe. It doesn't take me further, though. In general, it is a good thought that my ideas are so good that other people want to use them. It also helps me to know that they are so good that others say: we can make money from this ourselves. So it's not just something nonsensical, they see the business potential in it.
What did I do then? From top to bottom: In the first case, I opened a case with the association's ethics committee. Because it is unethical to proceed like this, to take an idea from someone else and turn it into your own product. That is not how we do business with each other. Quite apart from the fact that it is rather foolish to write an email like that.
It gives me a certain satisfaction to see that this product apparently isn't selling well in her hands.
In the second case, I sought direct contact, because we otherwise no longer have any point of contact. The contact was not reciprocated by the other side, who knows why. But that's not a problem. I know the previous Value Based Fee calculator inside out and have developed version 2.0: with more precise calculations and for the current needs of freelancers, for coaching and speaking. You can use it for free, so: help yourself.
In the third case, I am still in touch with the company. They were very surprised to hear that it comes with a cost. We are not yet at the point where they say they don't want it, or where they actually rebuild it. I could imagine that they won't, but I will keep reporting on it.
When Austin Kleon says "steal" in his book Steal Like an Artist, he does not mean copying. He distinguishes between good and bad stealing. Good is: studying, taking from many rather than from a single source, naming your sources and making something new out of what you took. Bad is: skimming, grabbing from one source, plagiarising, imitating. He also advises not taking the style, but the thinking behind the style.
Measured against that, nothing of good stealing is left in my three cases. The woman learned from me, copied my offer 1:1, didn't name me and presented herself as the developer. My colleague from the association transformed nothing, he kept my calculator and removed me. And rebuilding it, as the consulting company suggested in the meeting, would again be just a copy.
Stealing in Kleon's sense turns one idea into something new. Copying turns one idea into two identical ones.